When it comes to planning for retirement, a 401(k) is one of the most powerful tools available to employees. Yet, many Plan Sponsors remain unaware of the critical differences between the various types of advisors who manage these plans. One of the most significant distinctions lies in whether or not your 401(k) advisor is a fiduciary. Understanding this difference can have a profound impact on your retirement savings and financial security.

Why is it Important for an Advisor to be a Fiduciary?

An advisor who is a fiduciary is legally and ethically bound to act in the best interests of their clients. This means the advisor must prioritize your needs over their own potential gains, ensuring that their advice is free from conflicts of interest. Fiduciary duty encompasses a wide range of responsibilities, including:

  • Providing transparent and honest advice.
  • Avoiding conflicts of interest.
  • Disclosing any potential conflicts when they arise.
  • Ensuring that recommendations are in the best interest of the client.

The Contrast: Non-Fiduciary Advisors

On the other hand, non-fiduciary advisors operate under a different standard known as the suitability standard. While they are required to provide recommendations that are suitable for you, they are not necessarily obligated to put your interests above their own. This subtle but crucial distinction can lead to situations where the advice given is influenced by commissions, bonuses, or affiliations with certain financial products or companies.

The Risks of Working with Non-Fiduciary Advisors

Choosing a non-fiduciary advisor can expose you to several risks:

  • Conflicts of Interest: Non-fiduciary advisors may recommend products that offer them higher commissions rather than those that are best suited to your financial goals.
  • Higher Costs: You might end up paying more in fees and expenses for financial products that are not necessarily the best fit for you.
  • Lower Returns: Due to potential biases in investment advice, your portfolio might underperform compared to one managed by an advisor who is a fiduciary.

Have You Asked Yourself Why?

If your current 401(k) advisor is not a fiduciary and instead brings in a third party to act as the fiduciary, it’s essential to ask yourself why. Here are some questions to consider:

  • Transparency: Is your advisor fully transparent about their compensation and any potential conflicts of interest?
  • Motivation: Why is the advisor outsourcing fiduciary responsibility instead of taking it on themselves?
  • Third-Party Credibility: Is the third-party fiduciary reputable and do they have a track record of acting in the best interest of plan participants?
  • Alignment of Interests: How does the arrangement between your advisor and the third-party fiduciary ensure that your best interests are prioritized?
  • Direct Advisor’s Role: What role does your primary advisor play in managing your plan, and how do they ensure their recommendations are unbiased?
  • Participant Advice: Is the primary advisor providing impartial advice to plan participants about their investments and rollovers?
  • Accountability: Who is ultimately accountable for the advice given and the performance of your plan?

    By reflecting on these questions, you can better understand the motivations behind your advisor’s recommendations and whether they align with your 401(k) plan’s financial well-being.

    How to Tell if Your Advisor is a Fiduciary

    Determining whether your advisor is a fiduciary involves asking the right questions and understanding their responsibilities. Here are a few steps to help you identify a fiduciary advisor:

    • Ask Directly: Simply ask your advisor if they are a fiduciary, and if they are willing to put this commitment in writing and sign it.
    • Check Credentials: Look for designations such as Certified Financial Planner (CFP) or Registered Investment Advisor (RIA), as these often indicate fiduciary responsibility.
    • Review Their Compensation Structure: Fiduciaries typically charge fees for their advice rather than earning commissions on the products they sell.
    • Read the Fine Print: Carefully review any contracts or agreements to see if they mention fiduciary duty and what it entails.

      Making the Switch to a Fiduciary 401(k) Advisor

      If you decide that a fiduciary 401(k) advisor is a better fit for your retirement planning needs, transitioning to one doesn’t have to be complicated. Start by:

      • Researching fiduciary 401(k) advisors in your area or within your network.
      • Asking potential advisors about their fiduciary status and how they ensure their advice is free from conflicts of interest.
      • Evaluating their track record and approach to client service.


      As a Plan Sponsor, your 401(k) plan is too important to leave in the hands of an advisor who may not always act in your best interest. By choosing a fiduciary 401(k) advisor, you can have greater peace of mind knowing that your 401(k) plan and its participants are being guided with their best interests in mind.

      At Comperio Retirement Consulting, we pride ourselves on being fiduciaries for all our clients’ plans. This means you can trust that our advice and recommendations are always made with your best interests at heart. We also strive to educate our clients because the better informed they are about 401(k) plans and fiduciary responsibilities, the better decisions they can make for their company’s plan. If you would like to ask a Comperio advisor any questions with no obligations about this or any other topic we have published, click on the link below to schedule a 15-minute Teams meeting with a Comperio advisor of your choice.

      Click HERE to schedule a 15-minute Teams meeting with a Comperio advisor